The Other One > | 1977-11-04 | Grateful Dead

2:42:53
Rating:
9.50 / 16 ratings
Taper:
See info file
Transferrer:
Chris Chappell
SHNID:
gd1977-11-04.mtx.chappell.SB5.29091.flac16
Source:
Sick Bits Vol. 5 Matrix By Chris Chappell
Lineage:
See info file
Taper Notes:
View NotesSick Bits Vol. 5

Source:
Matrix: (SBD/AUD mix)

SBD: MR > DAT > CD-R (shn ID #2595)

AUD: MAC: Sony ECM 33Ps > Sony TC-158 > CDR (shn ID #15208)
Taped by Jerry Moore

[complete text files for each source appended at end]

Transfer/Editing:
Both sources were shn files downloaded from LMA and converted to
WAV > Vegas 5 (matrix) > WAV > CD Wave > FLAC Frontend > FLAC 16 (level 8)

Matrixed by Chris Chappell
[email protected]
4/23/05

General Notes:

Given the two sources available on the Llama, I decided to put the effort 
into editing a matrix of this weird and powerful night at Colgate U. 
during their homecoming weekend.  The Jerry Moore FOB AUD is an excellent 
recording, and the SBD is balanced with everyone in the mix and Keith 
featured prominently throughout.  The two sources work well together even 
though the venue was basically an ice rink with steel walls.

Music Notes:

This show, albeit sloppy at points, epitomizes the ability of the band to 
take chances musically, knowing they can falter at any moment but also
collectively discover something around the bend never before seen or heard.
This is also reflected in the setlist which has some noteworthy aspects.
The Let It Grow to end the first set is both out there and raging, 
purporting what is to come next.  Technical difficulties allow time for 
Phil to introduce the band as the "Jones Gang" at the start of the second 
set.  This level of hilarity is indicative of the playing to follow: loose,
strange, daring, and plain old rockin'.  Cold Rain & Snow hadn't been 
played in over a year and is one of two played in '77.  The Playin' in the 
Band is very exploratory building to a crescendo that segues into the gem 
of the show: Eyes of the World - simply the most rockin' I have heard.  
Then, to top it off, they transition into Estimated, with Jerry sort of 
happening upon the song unexpectedly.  This is the first Eyes > Estimated, 
with another on 11-5-79 and then not again until the famous night at Nassau 
with Branford Marsalis on 3-29-90.  A powerful one-verse only Other One 
follows, and then the 4th Iko-Iko ever comes out of Drums.  The Stella Blue 
is very intimate with Jerry crooning at the end similar to certain nights 
in the 90's.  A very long and jammed out Playin' reprise ends the set at
a fervent level, and the Johnny B. Goode to follow doesn't let up.
 
Editing Notes:

- Pitch
Both sources were pitched differently, the AUD being the sharpest, 
and the SBD being the flatest.  I used the SBD as my master timeline 
and pitch referenced the AUD to it. The AUD on average had to be pitched
down about .33 (33 cents) to achieve pitch correction - 1.00 being 
100 cents which is a semitone.  I did not reference A=440 as I did not 
desire to pitch adjust the SBD.  It is very close though to A=440.

- Synch 
Because of the speed fluctuation within a given source, multiple edits
were performed to keep the sources synched.  Because the SBD was my
master pitch and time ref, the AUD was synched to the SBD (too many
edits to list).

- Sonic Quality/Matrix ratio
The only dynamic processing I employed was a little bit of limiting 
(Waves L2) to the SBD source. All I was trying to do here is to add some 
dimension to the SBD by using the ambience of the AUD. The result is a 
lively but clear recording, hopefully close to how it sounded at the show. 
If I had to guess the SBD/AUD ratio would be somewhere between 3:1 and 4:1.

- Edits
The following are places where the SBD and AUD had splices, holes or
incomplete coverage in reference to the final matrix timeline. Crossfades
were used throughout for smooth transitions to a single source.

SBD:
d1t01 (0:00 - 0:03) - missing (crowd)
d1t02 (6:10 - 6:30) - missing (crowd)
d1t04 (4:49 - 4:53) - missing (crowd)
d1t05 (7:23 - 7:25) - missing (crowd)
d1t06 (4:10 - 4:23) - missing (crowd)
d1t07 (5:19 - 5:30) - missing (crowd)
d1t08 (6:09 - 6:13) - missing (crowd)
d2t01 (0:30 - 1:08) - missing 
d2t03 (6:10 - 8:18) - missing (crowd)
d3t01 (